Draft Charter
Status
This charter is an active proposal and has not yett been ratified as a formal part of rereading Project governance. For more information, please see the proposal discussion on Codeberg.
Mission
The primary focus of this project is to develop a tool and to foster a community around it for individuals and media providers to manage libraries of books and e-books, to make personal archives of those books, and to use their preferred apps and devices to read those books.
Principles
- A book is a work of art, and art is labor.
- A book is a relationship between an author or authors and their readers.
- Art and labor should not be enclosed by corporate interests, but should be a rich and flourishing part of human culture.
- Technology should enable but never undermine or circumvent that relationship.
- Readers should always be able to maintain their own personal libraries, independent of which publisher provided a given book, in what format, and for what device.
- Locking books to specific devices promotes e-waste and inhibits the accessibility of books.
- Technology should not enable corporations or governments to retroactively censor or remove books from individual readers’ libraries.
- Open source is an inherently political movement. Enabling readers to read books is similarly an inherently political action.
- Books should not disappear when publishers disappear, nor when e-book sellers disappear.
The rereading project does not include a prescription against AI as a guiding principle, but rather views an opposition to AI as a consequence of these principles — AI fundamentally changes the relationship between reader and author, and does so in a way that encloses art, displaces labor, and betrays readers' interests.
Scope
- A set of tools to enable readers to manage their library and media sources to more easily connect to readers.
- Primarily a set of cross-platform apps that allow for easy library management and personal book archival.
- A concept of a media source (for example, an independent publisher or e-book marketplace) that allows users to connect their account with that provider and sync their purchases.
Out of Scope
- DRM circumvention tools: The rereading project will take no actions that prevent the development and use of DRM circumvention tools, except to the extent that it is required to do so by law, but will not actively develop DRM circumvention tools.
- Mobile apps, e-reader devices, etc.: The rereading project aims to enable readers to use the devices and applications that are available to them; as such, the focus is on developing library management, conversion tooling, and other similar features.
Motivation
Reading and managing your library should not involve AI. With the increasing pressure from almost every tool and technology in use for managing libraries, there needs to be an option that will push back and be responsive to the needs of artists, writers, readers, and independent publishers.
Governance
Governance for the rereading project operates on the principles that: - In order to be successful at serving the interests of readers, writers, editors, publishers, and culture at large, the rereading project must be robust against poor decisions made by any individual member of the project. The project thus does not have any analogue to a director or “BDFL.” - Consent is an integral part of fair, equitable, and just leadership. As much as possible without compromising project goals or other project principles, the rereading project will adopt consensus methodologies to reflect this principle.
Governing Board
The Governing Board shall consist of the chairs of each of the following committees: - The Steering Committee - The Partnerships Committee - The Ethics Committee
The Governing Board responsibilities consist of: - setting the overall strategic direction of the rereading project, establishing main goals and identifying key priorities in accordance with feedback and input from the reading, writing, editing, and publishing communities; - managing the resources of the rereading project in a responsible and sustainable manner, including budget, infrastructure, and labor, both volunteer and employed; - adopting and maintaining policies or rules and procedures for the rereading project, such as a Code of Conduct and a trademark policy, and any compliance or certification policies.
Steering Committee
The Steering Committee shall be responsible for: - setting the technical direction of the rereading project, establishing main goals and identifying key technical priorities; - overseeing all software development processes and service hosting, ensuring that the underlying architecture enables these processes to run smoothly; - empowering labor, both volunteer and employed, by providing all the technical support necessary to achieve rereading’s mission; - establishing open collaboration with adjacent projects that are part of the community.
Partnerships Committee
The Partnerships Committee shall be responsible for: - planning and executing efforts to promote the rereading project to potential users and contributors; - organizing activities across events worldwide, both virtual and in person, to help solicit volunteer labor, to learn more about user needs, and to help readers and writers alike make use of the rereading project; - creating educational material (documentation, videos, blog posts, etc.) to help individuals and companies understand how to use and contribute to the rereading project; - managing communication across different channels (website, blog, social media, etc.); - developing and maintaining relationships with independent publishers and marketplaces, device manufacturers, relevant labor unions, and reader communities.
Ethics Committee
The Ethics Committee shall be responsible for: - developing and maintaining reporting and enforcement processes for Code of Conduct violations; - providing ethical oversight for the activities of the other Committees, including recommending the removal of members who violate project bylaws and policies; - facilitating moderation of public spaces hosted by the rereading project, including but not limited to group chats, mailing lists, and other similar venues.
Advisory Committee
The Advisory Committee shall have no formal rights, and in particular, shall have no corresponding position on the Governing Board; rather, the Advisory Board shall be responsible for providing advice, insight, and expertise to the Governing Board and other Committees by: - participating in infrequent meetings with members of the Governing Board; - preparing written advice to the Governing Board as required.
Members and Chairs
The Steering, Partnerships, and Ethics Committees are made up of community members with a sustained contribution over time, and recognized as interested in the long term health of the rereading project. Members of the Steering, Partnerships, and Ethics Committee recommend and appoint new members and decide on a Chair for each Committee to serve for a one-year term following a strong consensus decision process. New members must be approved by a strong consensus of all existing members. Members may be removed by a strong consensus of all other members, should other members decide that a removal is necessary to uphold project goals and ethical commitments. Members will be removed from the committee if resign or if they are inactive in participating and contributing to the project for more than 6 months.
Members of the Advisory Committee are appointed and removed by a strong consensus of the Governing Board members.
Meetings
Governing Board meetings will be limited to the Governing Board members. They will be public unless there is an explicit requirement for privacy, in which case as much of the reason for that requirement will be made publicly available as is possible. Steering, Partnerships, and Ethics Committee meetings should be held periodically (monthly or fortnightly) and are intended to be open to the public, held over openly available teleconferencing services. The chair for each Committee should set the agenda ahead of time and preside over the meetings. The meeting minutes should be published and shared with the community through public channels.
Decision Making
In the course of rereading project operations, three distinct decision making models will be made available to committee members, volunteers, and employees: - Strong consensus — all decision makers must actively agree on a particular decision; - Weak consensus — no decision makers must actively object to a particular decision; - Supermajority — a candidate decision must be actively approved by a two-thirds majority of the decision makers. Whenever possible, weak consensus processes should be used, except as prescribed in this charter. When a decision must be made by supermajority, the decision makers will be considered to be the members of the Steering, Partnerships, and Ethics Committees.
Amendments
Before a decision on a proposed amendment can be reached, the proposal must be made publicly available for no less than thirty days. Following that period, a supermajority of all current Committee members will be required for any amendment to this Charter. Amendments will be communicated to the community through public channels, and will take effect immediately.